Client Reviews, in Their Own Words.
57 reviews from buyers and sellers I’ve worked with around Western New York.
“Michelle is an amazing realtor. I have bought and sold many homes in two countries and she is hands down the best I have come across. You may think finding a property is the important part but it is closing the sale which takes skill and tenacity. Michelle never drops the ball she always works for your best interest and gets the deal closed. I highly recommend her!!”
Maryanne Campbell
“Michelle was nothing shy of amazing. She helped us find our 1st home. She took the time to explain everything and go above and beyond on examining the house with us. Anytime we had a question or concern, she was able to help us. Recommend her 100x to anyone looking for a house.”
Nick Carlos
“We had the best experience with Michelle! She was extremely knowledgeable, kind, and always went above and beyond! She kept you up to date on everything, and was only just a text away. She was always there to explain everything thoroughly, and answered all my silly questions. I really appreciate the patience and time she spent with us. She was really interested in getting her clients everything they asked for and more ! We couldn’t have been more pleased!”
Chryssymom
“Michelle is the best realtor you can imagine to have. She took care of everything from start to finish. Her attention to detail and exceptional communication makes her the best one on the market. I highly recommend her.”
Katarzyna Gore
“As a first time home seller, I just wanted to say how thankful I am for working with Michelle: she did an outstanding job selling my house! Throughout the process she was in constant communication, had a great marketing strategy, an excellent knowledge of the real estate process and most importantly a genuine passion for great customer service. Ultimately the numbers speak for themselves; after the first showing, we received multiple offers above the asking price! Thank you, Michelle!”
Dan Nethercott
“We have had a fantastic experience working with Michelle Petrie. She knew what needed to happen and when it needed to happen for us to sell our house quickly and for the best price. We will call her next time we sell a property and would recommend her to our friends.”
Nicholas Vespa
“Buying our first home was a nightmare, just a dream back in October. With realtors not answering me, and taking our house hunting adventure like a joke. But then in April, forces worked where we had Michelle become our agent. She works with the best of the best! She knows what she is doing, and she seriously has a gift! I’ll never work with another agent. She found us not only the perfect home, but the perfect neighborhood for us. She listens. She responds as fast as she can. And she made it go as smooth as she possibly could! She answered every question we had and if she didn’t know, she found out for us! Highly highly recommend!”
Heather Rushok
“Michelle was amazing! She answered every question I had, was extremely knowledgeable, and went to bat for me whenever needed. She worked around the clock, morning and night. I couldn’t be happier with my new home, and Michelle is the reason I was able to secure it in this aggressive market!”
Nicole Santora
“I would give Michelle 10 star’s if I could. We had come from out of state to sell our second home as soon as possible. I was told we should interview 3 agents but after speaking with Michelle for a few minutes it was easy that she was the agent we needed, she recommended a few low cost ideas and even had her people do them for us right away. We decided to have the home staged and after a few more days it was ready to be listed, the staging was incredibly her photographer was the best. Four days after listing we had 8 offers well over asking price she even took care of the house until closing because we couldn’t be there. If you need some one you can Trust completely then Michelle is the agent for you.”
Robert Walton
“While I was preparing to look for my first home, the whole process was intimidating when thinking about all the steps. Michelle did an amazing job at breaking it down, and assisting with the process, step by step. With her help, buying a home was such a smooth and easy process, and her knowledge was very helpful at helping me get from an apartment, and to my new house! Highly recommend!!”
Jason C
“I absolutely highly recommend Michelle for your home buying journey. She was the key to finding a home for me in this highly competitive market. She made every effort to show that I was an important client by understanding my needs, must haves, and targeting homes that was within my budget and the type of home I was looking for. Through every step of the process she checked on me and answered every question or concern I had. She responded quickly with new homes placed on the market and with scheduling walk-throughs with the seller. I cannot say enough about the professionalism and expertise she possesses.”
John Durolek
“Michelle was great! We appreciate all her hard work and professional advice. Our home was staged beautifully and the pictures showed the house’s true beauty. She made the process so easy on us and more than satisfied with the sale of our house. Highly recommend!”
Sean McDonough
“I was referred to Michelle by another realtor to help sell my father’s house in New York State (I reside in PA). I really needed someone who could help from 300+ miles away as well as work with my father who is older, has health issues and there were intricacies with his house sale that I had no idea how to handle. Not only did Michelle take care of my dad’s house sale flawlessly, she was also very patient, understanding and let my dad guide the way when possible. She kept him and I updated with every step and made sure we understood what she could provide and how to handle certain situations. On top of that, she went above and beyond with marketing and starting his house to the point that he honed he didn’t want to leave! In the end, my dad was more than happy with the experience (considering he wasn’t happy with me suggesting a realtor to begin with!). Michelle is always upbeat, very nice and gave my father all the time he needed and wanted. I couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. She cared about my father and whatever she could do to give him the best. She definitely did and I can’t thank her enough. If you’re lucky enough to haves chance to work with her, definitely jump at the opportunity. She’s awesome!”
Micah Fegley
Read all 57 reviews
“Michelle was an excellent realtor!! She was very attentive to all my needs and was with us the entire process from start to finish to make sure everything went as smooth as possible!!”
L Polowy
“Michelle was professional and accessible, we met with her early on and worked through our needs and she tailored her search to provide us with high quality listings every week. She is hands on and knowledgeable, we ran into several road blocks beyond our and her control and she was right there problem solving with us to get us into our dream home. We can not recommend her more highly and if we enter the market again we will be absolutely be looking to work with her.”
Ryan Smorol
“Michelle is extremely knowledgeable, professional and attentive. Best broker in Buffalo!”
Ben Cohn
“Michelle is the best! She’s clear in communication, she does her research and is incredibly patient. She’s always listening well and has been professional in our home buying process. At times when things were overwhelming, she was understanding and had a way of keeping it real with compassion. She is excellent and we can’t recommend her enough to anyone buying or selling a home.”
Stephanie “Steff” Finucane
“I have been working with Michelle and I can highly recommend her! She is extremely knowledgeable in the current real estate market and her follow up and overall customer service is impeccable!”
Vicki Copani
“Michelle was amazing to work with! She made it an easy process. She was always quick with communication and answered every question along the way. She helped us find the perfect house. I highly recommend Michelle for any of your real estate needs.”
Kristen Fleming
“We worked with Michelle to both buy our new home and sell our prior home and Michelle and her team made both as easy and pleasant as possible. She helped us curate our offer on our new house to give us the best chance possible and sure enough with her guidance we were chosen. She was receptive to our picky criteria and was smart about her approach to recommending which ones we should look at, and very patient with us when we were indecisive or didn’t communicate as well as we should have. And to sell our prior home she gave wonderful advice on how to make it marketable (landscaping, staging, what was worth doing to make it more marketable and what was not) and sure enough it sold quickly and the whole process went smoothly. In general she also educated and explained everything to us throughout both processes. We could not recommend Michelle highly enough!”
Christine Krol
“Very easy to work with, and very knowledgeable when it came to what expenditures would further benefit the sale thus avoiding unnecessary costs. Showings and perspective buyers were quickly brought in. I believe it took only one week. Closing papers and reports were always timely sent to two owners of the property, one of which resided out of state. Michelle could always be easily contacted if any questions arose throughout the sales experience.”
Tom Kaczorowski
“If you’re looking for someone to take the stress out of the home buying process, look no further than Michelle. Michelle is well versed in all areas of WNY and helped me find my perfect home. From our initial meeting Michele was extremely engaged and was there through every step of the home buying process to answer all of my questions, no matter the day/time. I recommend Michelle to all of my family and friends, she is truly one of the good ones! Thank you Michelle!!”
Mark Boudreau
“Michelle is an amazing realtor. She helped my boyfriend and I buy our first home and made the process so easy. She was very prompt, honest, and thorough. I will be recommending her to all of my friends!”
Marissa Parent
“My girlfriend and I were first time home buyers with absolutely zero knowledge on what to expect or look for. But after a few showings with Michelle we felt like seasoned pros. She made the entire process a breeze and was always accessible to us and our laundry list of questions as if we were her only clients. We are forever grateful to Michelle for helping us find our perfect first home, and we couldn’t be happier.”
Anonymous
“As first time home buyers, my boyfriend and I had no idea what we were doing. We walked into Michelle’s office with no experience and barely an idea of what we were looking for. Michelle was able to guide us through the entire process and answer all of our questions. She never looked down on us or made us feel dumb for not knowing the answers. We always felt like Michelle looked out for us and gave us her honest opinion which was really important to us. When we are ready to sell our home and buy new, we will definitely be reaching out to Michelle again (and recommending her to our friends and family!)”
Adriana
“Michelle was my best friend through this process. A real rock you can lean on! She will be honest with you, will never cut corners or do anything “shady” . Highly responsive, and will go over every detail with you that you have questions about. Believe me, I am the most annoying pain in the but when it comes to understanding the process and she was patient with me and stayed on the phone with me for up to an hour sometimes until I understood things and we were on the same page. We will be recommending her to our friends and will remember her if we ever move again. We probably won’t be moving because she found us and fought for and got the perfect house for us!”
Ana D.
“I couldn’t have asked for an easier experience than the one I had selling my home with Michelle. This was my first time selling, and although I would contact her several times with questions, she was more than patient to explain them clearly and walk me through the whole process. Highly recommend!”
Matt Geltz
“Michelle was exactly what I needed. Going through a rough period in my life, not only did Michelle help me find a new home, she helped me find one I love, and find it fast! The entire process with Michelle was unbelievably smooth and easy, from day 1 she laid out what to expect, what to do and what our timeline looks like. We’ve stayed true to that plan since then and her experience and knowledge has been invaluable guiding me along the way. She knew the in’s and out’s of what to look for in the home, how to make my bid more appealing and quite honestly just had an attitude that I needed. Michelle brought a positive attitude and great energy to the experience. I highly highly recommend talking with her as your begin your home buying/selling journey.”
Andy K.
“Michelle is one of the most patient and caring person I’ve ever met! Always willing to help me and my partner to get the Best out of what we are looking for!!”
Justa Moon
“My partner and I were referred to Michelle through our bank as first time home buyers. From the beginning, Michelle guided us through the home buying experience working with us to find a house that met our specifications. Michelle was very knowledgeable and was able to answer any questions we had as we went and she worked diligently to help us fully understand the entire process. She is personable and makes herself available to her clients at all times, even working with us while she was on vacation at one point. We are very thankful for her help finding us our ideal first home.”
Emily Bannister
“Michelle Petrie is extraordinary. She helped us sell and purchase a house within the past year and is exceptional in every way. I cannot imagine navigating a real estate transaction without her. Perhaps her most impressive quality is her ability and commitment to genuinely connect with each client on a personal level. Michelle intently takes the time to understand her client’s needs and sincerely advocates in their best interest. Her professionalism, knowledge, compassion, accessibility, and communication are unmatched! Despite her expansive portfolio, Michelle always made us feel like we were her only client. She flawlessly marketed our house to include stunning professional photography, 3D walkthrough, and open house resulting in multiple offers 15% and higher above asking price. During the purchase of our subsequent home, she was equally impressive. She helped us secure a winning offer on our dream house, below asking price, and expertly got us to the closing table ahead of schedule. Whether you’re buying or selling, Michelle and her team are the epitome of top-tier, and I wouldn’t trust anyone else.”
Steve
“Michelle and her team are awesome! They realized my process wasnt going to be quick nor easy. Michelle was super patient and never pushed me in a direction I didnt want to go in. She gave me multiple options until we found the right house. Would recommend her to everyone!”
Robert Milewski
“The Petrie team with Michelle Petrie at the helm gave me personal and an absolutely awesome experience in selling my home. They led me step by step with complete updates and information. You couldn’t ask for a better realtor company. If you are looking to sell or buy a home, definitely look them up. You will not be disappointed but completely satisfied. Three thumbs up!!”
Paulina
“Thank you for helping us sell Mom’s home! You made it easy for us as out-of-state residents!”
Ajit Nemi
“Michelle was easy to reach and super responsive to any questions we had. We appreciated her advice and help in closing the deal on our new home.”
Heidi Dobmeier
“Michelle and Krystina were the best part of this whole experience. They are both extremely knowledgeable and compassionate. They worked with me through ups and downs and were not just looking at the potential financial gain. I would recommend them to anyone!”
Lashae Adams
“Michelle recently helped my husband and I through the home buying process for our first family (dream) home. Working with her was an absolute joy. Michelle took extraordinary care in understanding and perusing exactly what it was we were looking for. Her positive energy and obvious expertise made what would have otherwise been a very overwhelming experience, instead, enjoyable and educational. Her communication skills are unmatched. Her dedication to her clients and career make her the incredible agent she is and I would recommend her to anyone as they move forward in the home selling & buying process. We are so grateful we had the chance to work with her.”
Kristen Maciejewski
“We had an amazing experience with Michelle purchasing our home. She is an excellent agent; prompt, responsible, and easy to work with. She was there for us every step of the way, guiding us through the process. Thank you, Michelle!”
Alesya
“From start to finish in the selling process, Michelle went above and beyond. Her knowledge and expertise were top-notch. The initial assessment, her approach, staging and even the dreaded paperwork were made effortless because of her knowledge and joy she finds in her job. We are so grateful to have done business with her.”
Alissa K.
“Michelle hustled to go to a last minute showing at what ended up being my dream home. The offer was accepted, so it was meant to be. Timing was everything with this deal. I am grateful for her expertise and guidance. While it was a tough market to be a first-time home buyer, once under contract, she made the process as seamless and expedient as possible, keeping in perfect communication. Now I’m at peace in my forever home, which what I was hoping for. Couldn’t be any more comfortable and happier!”
Paula
“Michelle was totally helpful and a pleasure to work with. I thought buying a house would be a difficult challenge but instead I feel it was like having the red carpet rolled out in front of me. This includes the professionals that she recommended. I believe Michelle had my back. As we looked at houses, she was almost as critical as an inspector would be so that my eyes were wide open to the pros and cons of each possibility. I highly recommend Michelle and happy house hunting!”
J.H.
“Michelle is the best! so thorough and knowledgeable. She taught me so much that I feel like I could become an agent now haha! she’s basically like having an inspector and contractor and realtor all in one. You can tell that she isn’t there to just “make a sale”; there were houses that I would have bought if it wasn’t for her better judgement and telling me we should keep looking. Highly recommend hiring Michelle to find you the perfect home!”
Kelsey C
“Michelle was referred by a friend and has been a blessing. I was selling a rental property that I had owned for 20 years and Michelle did a fantastic job of marketing to get the best price possible. She took the lead with all of the tenants and made them feel very comfortable with a process that can be difficult at times. She had professional pictures taken and the showing was excellent. I got more than I was looking for and it was a a great success. All due to Michelle’s great work ethic.”
Jack Carrig
“Working with Michelle was an absolute dream from start to finish. She is incredibly supportive and patient, taking the time to answer every question and making sure we felt confident at every step. At the same time, she’s a fierce advocate who truly fights for her clients and works tirelessly to get the best possible outcome. Beyond her professionalism and effectiveness, she’s simply fun to work with; positive, responsive, and genuinely invested in our success. We couldn’t have asked for a better partner in this process and would recommend her wholeheartedly to anyone looking to buy or sell a home (she did both for us)!”
Brandon Canfield
“Made what seemed like the daunting task of purchasing our first home, easy, friendly and exciting. My wife and I couldn’t be happier with her transparency and help navigating each step of a home buyers journey. Will definitely use her again when looking for more property or another home in the future!”
Nicholas Rice
“Michelle was such a joy to work with! She is a wealth of knowledge and taught us so much about the home buying process. Her team is dynamite and kept us updated throughout our entire timeline. She is the best!”
Rhiannon Burger
“When my girlfriend and I met Michelle and Kristina around August 2024 we told them we didn’t want to buy a house until May/June 2025. We were cautious and new to the game. Well… we bought a home November 2024. The Petrie team did an amazing job making this process so easy and smooth! They didn’t rush us into a home but truly made sure we loved our decision. Their expertise and dedication goes a long way. I’d recommend to anyone, Petrie team will have your back!”
Mitchell Feneziani
“I work the Denver Colorado area and was referred to Michelle through our Tom Ferry platforms. Michelle is absolutely top notch. The transaction ended up having underlying problems and moving parts that weren’t expected, however, she handled them with professionalism and ease. I will be referring all future transactions in that area to Michelle because I know she will be on top of it to get it done! If you haven’t had the pleasure of working with Michelle for your New York purchases, you need to buy property just to experience working with her.”
David Heine
“Michelle does such a professional job in every aspect! She is easy to communicate with and answers all questions quickly. She is very knowledgable in the market and trends. We would highly recommend her, WNY Roberts for anyone looking to sell or buy.”
Jane Meier
“I needed a Realtor to sell my mom’s house as part of an estate. From our first meeting, it was clear that Michelle was an amazing Realtor. She was always available to answer any questions and kept in contact every step of the way. Very Grateful for her kindness, Professionalism and Knowledge…. and a quick sale.”
Melissa Schenck
“Michelle did a fantastic job and helped us get our dream home in an incredibly competitive and chaotic market. She gave us great advice, was supremely responsive and supportive, works extremely hard, consistently maintains a positive attitude (despite challenges and curveballs), and is just a great person overall. Thanks Michelle!”
Matt C.
“Michelle is great agent, very knowledgeable and responsible. She was always there to answer our questions and guide us in the right direction through the home buying process. She was excellent at negotiating and completing all the necessary steps on time. I would recommend her as an agent and she would guarantee a great experience. Thank you so much, Michelle!”
Richard
“Michelle was fantastic from start to finish. She handled every detail to make the selling process as simple as possible. I would highly recommend her for any real estate need that anyone might have.”
Jim M
“Michelle made the selling process of our home so incredibly easy. Her knowledge and attention to detail is unmatched! I can not thank her enough for such an amazing selling experience!!I have and will continue to recommend her to anyone in need of buying or selling a home!”
Andrea
“Michelle Petrie was my realtor and she was extremely helpful. Very knowledgeable in what she does and she helped me a great deal. Even during the tough times that we were in and everything through the roof, she found me a lovely home and I am grateful for all of the hard work she did to make it as easy as possible for us. I would highly recommend this company and Michelle for a realtor. 5 stars all day.”
Stephen A.
“Michelle did an excellent job helping me find my first home. From our first meeting, she walked me through what the process was going to look like and what to expect. She was always quick to respond whenever I had a question or saw a house come on the market. This was invaluable especially with current market conditions. Michelle defiantly exceeded my expectations, and I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home (and I plan to do so!!) Thanks Michelle!”
Louie T
“From the moment I first met Michelle Petrie I got a good feeling she would be a great choice for me to sell my home. Her personality and kindness extended to my daughter and granddaughters warmed my heart. Her knowledge, confidence and most of all her strategy, I thought was excellent ! Everything she promised me came true ! Michelle actually took money out of her pocket to pay for a few extra accents she thought would add a little extra touch to my home. Yes, I reimbursed her ! LOL She sold my home to the very 1st person who viewed my home. I would like to add, Michelle’s sensitive side to my emotional attachment to my home home was extremely important to me. She immediately began searching for my next home purchase. I would rate her as 5 star and definitely recommend her. If your looking to sell or purchase a home to contact Michelle !”
Jay Scire
What’s Your Home Worth Today?
Tell me a little about your home and get a free analysis of its approximate value on the market today.
Or call or text 716-293-2817